Judging People Based on Their Actions
As I was eating breakfast this morning, I was thinking about people and their actions. I was eating pancakes made from the New Otani pancake mix. It’s more convenient than making my own pancakes from scratch. The New Otani mix comes with two pouches of mix (so you don’t have to open it all at once) and some syrup. There used to be two pouches of syrup, one for each pouch of pancake mix. It seems they have changed to having four half pouches of syrup. Perhaps making it easier for two people sharing one pouch of pancake mix.
Anyway, back to people’s actions. One thing I’ve heard foreigners say in Japan is that Japanese line up and sit on the train very nicely, hands folded in their laps, legs kept close so as not to get in the way of other people. This is true. The interesting thing is that the tone in most foreigners’ voices suggests that they view this action and the Japanese who perform it as being inferior. The lining up and sitting nicely are learned behaviors and in my opinion rather efficient. There is nothing to suggest any type of inferiority. In this case, I think I should refrain from judging people based on their actions. When I say judging people, I mean assigning them a number based on the strength/value of their character/personality. This has nothing to do with their type of personality but the goodness or value of their character.
In contrast to Japanese on the train, I think it is quite appropriate to judge a murderer based on his or her criminal behavior. There’s a whole continuum of situations in between…..at what point does an action go from being an illegitimate to legitimate basis for judgement?